March 5, 2010
When it comes to morale, all of the news seems to be bad. Seventy-two percent of companies reduced their work forces in 2009, according to HR firm Towers Watson.
In addition, many more companies cut benefits, eliminated training, placed workers on unpaid furloughs and froze salaries.
There’s no doubt that this trouble will affect employee engagement. Instead of feeling lucky that they still have jobs — after all, one in 10 U.S. workers are unemployed — workers are increasingly disgruntled, according to a survey released by the Conference Board on Jan. 5. Only 45 percent of those surveyed said that they were happy with their jobs, which has decreased from 61 percent in 1987.
But smart companies are using the economic crisis as a way to connect with employees, despite the need to make painful decisions. Others are taking advantage of a brightening financial picture in order to build a new sense of community.
What are companies doing to stem the tide of disengagement? Communicators at a number of companies said that, despite the obstacles, they are using a variety of ways to make a positive impact on morale.
It’s best, of course, to always tell people the truth. However, during challenging times, it’s human nature — especially for empathetic leaders — to want to soften the impact of bad news.
At hotel chain Marriott International, Inc., communicators helped counsel leaders to “be as transparent as they could be,” says Matthew Papuchis, manager, communications and change management, sales and marketing.
Putting news in context
Georgia-Pacific, one of the world’s biggest manufacturers of paper, packaging and building products, also followed the play-it-straight philosophy but added another ingredient: context.
“Over the past year or so, the economic news has been extremely confusing. So we felt it was critical to provide context about what it meant to our business,” says Steve Church, senior director, business communications, at the 45,000-employee company. “Our employees are smart, but the economic picture was so murky that it was sometimes difficult for them to connect the dots.”
As a result, Georgia-Pacific spent a lot of time educating its employees about key economic issues. For example, since one of the company’s main product lines is building materials, leaders provided an in-depth look at the housing market.
“This context helped employees understand why the company needed to make certain business decisions,” says Church. “That goes a long way [for] retaining trust.”
Looking at the whole picture
Many employees have experienced the past several years as a series of losses, including the 401(k) match, health benefits and salary increases, among other job benefits.
How should communicators provide information about pay and benefits? It begins with candor, says Barbara Zajac, senior consultant, communications, for Towers Watson. Communicators have to go beyond simply delivering one piece of bad news after another, she says.
“Employees often don’t understand the full spectrum of benefits their companies offer,” says Zajac. “That’s why, especially in a time of cutbacks, you need to step back and provide information about the whole array of benefits.”
“Perks like time off and flexible work arrangements continue to matter to employees,” she adds. “When employees know what’s available, their satisfaction increases.”
It’s also important to keep listening to employees talk about what they care about. For example, at Marriott, a small thing — like the ability to wear jeans on Fridays in the summer — lifted people’s moods. So the company extended this policy into the fall, and then instituted casual Fridays, when employees may wear jeans in the office.
Leading by example
How you shape messages and the story that you tell are an imperative part of building trust. But who is delivering those messages is just as critical.
“It’s all about leaders,” says Paulette Gabriel, owner of Key Leadership Initiatives, a management consulting firm. “The fastest way to create disengagement is for leaders to hunker down and become invisible. Tough times call for a high-touch approach to leadership: getting in front of people, being transparent, making personal connections.”
That “high-touch” approach to leader communication has been a key strategy for Thermo Fisher Scientific, an equipment and service provider for life sciences and health care markets.
Ginger Kuenzel, director, employee communications, at Thermo Fisher, explains, “We make sure our leaders are role models. For example, our CEO has done a good job of visiting sites and meeting people. But with 35,000 employees, it’s impossible for senior leaders to reach everyone personally.”
So in 2009, Kuenzel led a program to improve local town halls and forums. “Employees want face-to-face contact with the leader they know and trust,” she says. “But in the past, although our leaders usually had good intentions, the experience was sometimes lacking — town halls were too static and not interactive enough.”
The town hall program involves employee teams made up of people from multiple job functions and levels at every site.
“The team offers suggestions about how to structure the session, develops agenda items and provides feedback,” says Kuenzel. “The result has been dramatic: Leaders feel supported and more confident, and employees report that town halls are more dynamic, more participatory and more useful.”
Creating a community
One of the most important jobs for leaders, especially during tough economic times, is to communicate that everyone’s in the same situation.
More leaders are speaking not only at formal gatherings like town hall meetings, but also in informal settings like company cafeterias. They’re also expressing empathy and appreciation. As Gabriel explains, the upside of bad times is that leaders present a chance to create a new sense of community.
“The past decade was all about being fast and first,” she says. “Tough times forced us to slow down and reassess. And what many people concluded is that what really matters is connecting to one another. Leaders who realize this have the opportunity to engage employees, even in a down economy.”
Many company spokespeople offered examples of employees coming together, from potluck holiday gatherings to volunteer days.
Sharing good news
After all of the grief of recent years, the next opportunity for many communicators is sharing good news. That’s the scenario facing Matt Evans, communication manager, global organizational advancement/human resources, for the Timken Company, which produces bearings and steel products.
“Last year, the company made difficult decisions to protect our balance sheet, including work force reductions in professional and operative associates, cost-cutting initiatives, furloughs, and a divestiture,” says Evans. “The good news is that we’re prepared for the rebound in our markets.”
For example, Timken recently communicated the restoration of the company match to the 401(k) and international retirement plans, and informed employees that the furlough program concluded at the end of 2009.
Remembering the rules
For those of us who have forgotten how to communicate good news, what are the rules?
“The same principles apply. It’s about respect, and treating people like adults,” says Evans. “ Involve leaders and managers so they can answer associates’ questions. Give people warning so they’re not surprised. And above all, be candid and transparent.”
Doing so, he says, has a significant payoff, no matter what you’re communicating. “Our associates have been through some tough times,” Evans says. “But they know they matter to the company. When it comes to building morale, that makes all the difference.”